On Saturday, The Conservative Treehouse posted an article about a yacht club on Long Island that was forced to close its restaurant because the staff was deported due to immigration enforcement.
The article reports:
The larger picture is well worth discussing, because there is a large and inorganic part of the U.S. economy that will obviously be impacted by immigration enforcement and the removal of illegal or unauthorized workers.
If you business model won’t work without illegal cheap labor, maybe there is a problem with your business model.
The article notes:
There are resorts and venues operating in the USA which never would have been built without a foundation of foreign labor to service them. Take that labor force out of the economy and things will significantly change. This outcome is both predictable and necessary to reset the labor market.
As all of these foreign workers are removed there is going to be massive pressure on the wage rates for American workers. That’s a great benefit. Simultaneously, there’s also some businesses that will never survive without that foreign labor pool because the business model itself was built upon a false foundation.
Most of the time we think about the service industries with workforces that are significantly staffed with foreign workers. Hotels, resorts, restaurants, vacation destinations etc. Many of these locations currently operating would never have found capital or investment in a true economy that was not built on illegal immigration, visas or foreign workers. There are likely hundreds of resorts that exist only because the labor market is inorganic.
With a predictable rise in wages comes the increased operating costs and diminished profit return for the investors and owners. This can have a major impact, but again, this outcome is due to fraud in the underlying business model. Those businesses likely would never have started and the investment never would have been capitalized without the fraud it is dependent upon.
Take out the illegal aliens; remove the H1B visas and all other ancillary visa approvals and remove the protected status returning foreign workers to their country of origin, and U.S. wage rates and benefits will quickly increase as companies try to find a way to shift to a business model built upon real economics.
This rise in wages will be significant and that can create an inflation increase. As wages increase in price, the operating costs increase. The per unit business model then must adjust and things like hotel rooms go up in price. As resort prices increase, they become unaffordable to the current target customer, that leads to lower sales and decreased revenue. However, that natural dynamic also returns organic competition to a market that has been missing competition for decades.
It’s not just about the service industries. As the labor market contracts, wage rates for blue collar construction and manufacturing jobs also increase. This can lead to higher consumer prices during the painful phase as the natural market balance is restored. Again, many businesses will not exist because many businesses never would have existed without the baseline of imported foreign workers.
It is time to enforce the law so that American workers can take these jobs and be paid what the jobs should pay.
