Prayers and condolences to the family of the young child who has died of swine flu in Texas. The Washington Post has the details. However, there are a few things that are interesting about this story. Some questions have answers, some don’t.
The child had traveled by plane from Mexico City to a Mexican town near the US border on April 4. He crossed the border into Brownsville to visit relatives and developed symptoms on April 8th. He was admitted to Brownsville Hospital and later transferred to a Houston hospital when he did not improve. OK, here come the heartless questions and observations.
1. Did the child enter the country legally?
2. Did you notice that American hospitals treat people from other countries? We have the best and most generous healthcare system in the world. There is no mention of any sort of health insurance.
3. The story says his relatives are healthy and have not shown any symptoms. How long is the incubation period on this disease and should we quarantine them knowing they have been exposed?
According to an article in the Baltimore Sun:
“Meanwhile, the commandant of the Marine Corps said a Marine in southern California might have the illness and 39 Marines were being confined until tests come back. General James Conway told a Pentagon briefing an initial test indicated the sick Marine — who was not identified — might have swine flu but his illness did not appear life-threatening.”
As usual, the military’s response to this situation is much more logical than that of the people currently in power in Washington. As other countries are restricting or putting up travel warnings regarding Mexico, we are leaving open a very porous border. The Mexican border needs to be closed until we learn more about the disease, how long the incubation period is, and how long people with it are contagious.
Early this week the Democrats told the Republicans they would have a “celebrity witness” for this morning’s hearing on the Waxman/Markey Bill, but they would not say who. The Republicans immediately contacted me and asked if they could tell the Dems they too were putting forward an undisclosed celebrity witness – me.
When the Dems eventually revealed that their “celebrity” was Al Gore, the Republicans told them I was to testify at the same time. The Dems immediately refused to allow the Republicans their first choice of witness. By the time they had refused, my jet was already in the air from London and I did not get the message till I landed in the US.
At first the Dems tried to refuse the Republicans the chance to replace me with a witness more congenial to them, but eventually – after quite a shouting-match – they agreed to let Newt Gingrich testify. The former Speaker of the House gave one of his best performances.
I attended the session anyway, as a member of the public, and tried to shake hands with Gore when he arrived, but his cloud of staffers surrounded him and he visibly flinched when I called out a friendly “Hello” to him.
His testimony was as inaccurate as ever. He repeated many of the errors identified by the High Court in the UK. He appeared ill at ease and very tired – perhaps reflecting on the Rasmussen poll that shows a massive 13.5% swing against the bedwetters’ point of view in just one year.
My draft testimony will be posted at http://www.scienceandpublicpolicy.org shortly, together with a brief refutation of Gore’s latest errors.
Finally, I have never said what one of your less polite correspondents has said I said about HIV. However, in 1987, at the request of the earliest researchers into the disease, I wrote articles in journals on both sides of the Atlantic recommending that AIDS should be treated as a notifiable disease, just like any other fatal, incurable infection. Had that standard public-health measure been taken – immediate, compulsory, permanent, but humane isolation of the then rather few carriers – many of the 25 million (UNAIDS figures) who have died and the 40 million who are currently infected and heading for death would have been spared. Sometimes, unfashionable points of view are right, and sometimes ignoring them can be a matter of life and death.”