The use of Flock cameras in America is increasing. On Thursday, The Patriot Post posted an article about their use and the legal concerns surrounding their use.
The article reports:
Frustration has been growing across the country over the expanded use of Automated License Plate Reader (ALPR) cameras. Flock cameras, produced by a company called Flock Safety, are automated cameras with a system that tracks vehicles, scanning their license plates, make, model, and even physical characteristics like dents and roof racks.
With some 110,000 of these Flock cameras across the nation, vandalism and cutting down the stands or poles on which the devices are mounted have become common as a form of protest against the use of these systems.
Some people see Flock cameras as a violation of their privacy rights. Flock Safety CEO Garrett Langley defended his company, claiming that safety “is a fundamental right” he guards. It’s unclear where Langley got that idea, since it can’t be found anywhere in the Constitution. The Fourth Amendment protects “against unreasonable searches and seizures.” It does not provide for safety.
However, Langley is correct in arguing against the vandalizing of Flock cameras, noting that “we live in a beautifully democratic, capitalistic country where we can fight in court.” Destroying Flock cameras over what one considers a violation of Fourth Amendment privacy rights is not the way to fight such potential abuse.
The arguments against Flock cameras are that they serve as a de facto mass surveillance system that effectively records vehicle traffic — and more. However, Flock Safety is not a government entity but rather a private company that contracts with local police departments for access. Technically, it is not the government that is actively keeping tabs on public traffic, though that may be a distinction without a difference.
The government gets away with the surveillance because technically they are not the ones doing the surveillance. I understand the desire for safety and security, but I don’t think Flock cameras are the solution to our safety concerns. The real answer to crime in America is to encourage marriage and intact families. According to the CDC, in 2024, almost 40% of all births in America were to unmarried women. Children who grow up in one-parent households are much more likely to become criminals as adults. We don’t need more surveillance–we need stronger families.