Lady Liberty is a North Carolina blogger who also attended the Academic Standards Review Commission meeting yesterday. She posted the following letter from another person who was there. This is the letter:
I was one of several attendees at the ASRC Event today. The pro Common Core member of this commission who was the architect of what took place today was brilliant.
First, the order of the meeting to pass all the ELA Sub Committee’s recommendations with unanimous votes. Of course there was nothing contentious in these recommendations, since the best I can tell, it merely restated the S812 bill expectations of this committee. The committee met for 15 months to simply send back to the General Assembly a restatement of their assignment? The General Assembly will no doubt be impressed! But what happened next was the genius part. Making what appeared to be a friendly recommendation to improve on the Math Sub Committee’s recommendations in the “Draft” document. It was even stated, this can only reinforce the Math Sub Committee’s recommendations. All this took place before the documented recommendations for the math were even allowed to be discussed. Then witnessing the aggressive attack on Dr. Scheik, whose sub-team did more real work on evaluating standards than the original authors of CCSS, that resulted in failure of all those recommendations to pass the committee vote. This is when it became crystal clear to me why there was such a push to copy the ELA recommendations to the Math recommendations! Since none of the math recommendations passed during the voting process, the commission would have had NO math recommendations in their final report. Absolutely brilliant!
I referenced this as an event in lieu of a meeting, since it was so well orchestrated. I was impressed by the leadership exhibited in the meeting today by Dr. Scheik, who held to his principals to the bitter end against all odds. It is disgraceful that this commission would work for 15 months on an assignment to make recommendations and have other members who took no part in the work team, ambush them in this manner. Real leaders would have done the hard work through the process to develop recommendations of substance, that were acceptable to the majority. Instead, they just hung around and waited for the opportunity to snipe the work. With this level of leadership (that includes two State School Board members), it is no surprise to see their steadfast resolve to stay the course on a failed process.
I feel really bad for those commissioners who worked their heart and soul to positively impact the education of our great state of North Carolina, only to have it erased in such a circus event. I know this was a huge personal sacrifice for those people.
This is far from over since the future of our children is worth fighting for.
Glenn A. Fink
Thank you, Glenn.